January 19, 2012 § 2 Comments
I didn’t take too many notes at AdaCamp, partly because I wanted to be participating fully and partly to respect that we were working under Chatham House rules (which I think will probably be modified for future conferences, as many participants seemed happy to be identified). This summary is therefore quite general, and will just pick up on some of the themes and ideas that came up in the sessions. There’s also a brief wrap-up over at the Ada Initiative blog which links to other posts about the camp.
The first session I went to was on mothering/caring friendly spaces. Several of the participants spoke about the ways in which many geeky spaces marginalise children, which can also make parents feel unwelcome. For example, children are often uniformly banned from hackerspaces, rather than creating safe areas for younger children and/or recognising that older children can work on potentially-risky equipment as long as they’re given the right training. People raised a number of different potential strategies for dealing with this, including asking people to think back to their own experiences when they were young and trying to support mentoring programmes. At a more abstract level, I also think that it’s important to actively address the ways in which caring work is gendered: to encourage more men to recognise the value of caring work and to participate in it.
There were plenty of links between this session and the following one on how to teach and learn about feminism in geek communities. People shared some great ideas on creative strategies for making material available (like using videos and comments), as well as potential issues with some of these strategies (women talking about feminism in a video that allows comments are almost certain to experience a heap of draining harassment, including comments on their appearance). We also talked about ‘magic man sparkles': the tendency for people to pay attention to messages from men that they ignore or react to with hostility when coming from women. I feel quite conflicted about actively trying to use ‘magic man sparkles’ to get the message across: on the one hand it feeds into sexism, but on the other it allows allies to play a role in supporting the movement and it can be quite an effective strategy.
The session on gendered divisions of labour within geek communities had some great input from participants working in open tech and culture – I really appreciated the chance to hear more about this from the perspective of women working in FOSS and related areas. For example, people talked about the ways in which hierarchies of value play out in FOSS communities, with developers seen as most important and contributions of designers, testers, administrative workers, and other non-coding areas being marginalised. People also raised some interesting questions about the methodology for assessing contributions: someone pointed out that studies showing very little participation from women in Wikipedia may be skewed because women might be making small contributions without logging in, or may not feel comfortable identifying their gender online.
The session on ‘open * philosophy’ and the links between different ‘open’ projects was perhaps the most interesting to me, given my background. Many of the participants at AdaCamp came from programming or other open tech backgrounds and are largely self-taught in feminism, which they drew on in really nuanced and interesting ways during the discussions. However, there seemed to be less awareness of some of the political philosophies and traditions that might be useful when thinking about women in open tech and culture. This is understandable: not everyone has time to wade through a heap of political philosophy, especially when some of the more relevant work has been incorporated into feminist theory/practice. One of the ways in which I’d like to contribute to the ongoing discussion around AdaCamp is to put together a short reading list for anyone who is interested in learning more about potentially-useful political ideas. If you have anything you think should be on the list, let me know in the comments.
I’m very glad that I went to AdaCamp. As several people noted in the wrap-up session, it was an inspiring and restorative experience to be able to talk knowing that there were certain basic understandings in place about things like feminism and privilege. It was also great to meet so many people that I’ve come across online, and many others who I hadn’t (including a few from Perth). I’m looking forward to continuing the conversations that began at AdaCamp over the coming months.
January 11, 2012 § Leave a comment
After spending the last year or so heavily focused on teaching, I’m trying to find space for research and writing again. As part of that plan, I’ll be starting off the year by attending AdaCamp this weekend in Melbourne, and the Technology Conference 2012 in LA next week.
AdaCamp is an unconference organised by the Ada Initiative, “a non-profit organization dedicated to increasing participation of women in open technology and culture, which includes open source software, Wikipedia and other open data, and open social media.” There’ll be some academics working in my field present, but also activists and people from other backgrounds. The sessions which have been offered over the mailing list so far sound great, and I appreciate the thought that is being put into making sure that AdaCamp is a safe and welcoming space for participants.
Technology conference 2012 is a much more traditional academic event, although I do like that they’ve incorporated talking circles into the conference programme. I don’t have experience with talking circles, but they sound like they might be a good way to get real discussion happening. It’s also great to see that the plenary speakers for the conference are a little more diverse than at many other conference I’ve been too (but, sadly, all still white and from a Western background as far as I can tell). My paper will be on the ways in which social movement scholars understand technological change, drawing heavily on the research I carried out in India early last year.
If you’re going to either event, please feel free to say hello in the comments or while I’m there. Coming all the way from Perth it’s always good to see a friendly face!